First, let it be known that I have not read the book mentioned in this title. Rather, I heard about it and heard the author speak on one of my least favorite public radio programs – To The Best Of Our Knowledge. I dislike it partly because it is a locally produced program that never seems to offer real insight into anything and also because the show’s title makes it seem that I could host a program that’s just as good. I would call it As Far As I Know.
Anyway, Mr. McKibben reveals some stunning information in this book – more stuff does not equal more happiness! When I heard him make this revelation, I was shocked. Why is a program distributed by Public Radio International wasting time on this guy? Everyone with any education already knows this fact. In fact, if you are still under the delusion that owning more stuff makes you happy, then maybe you are one of those people for whom material wealth is all that is required to be happy. Cheers for you! For the rest of us, we figured it out a long time ago. Remember being a kid and spending your money on something that didn’t live up to your expectations? Remember how the disappointment of learning that a certain toy wasn’t as cool as you thought was so much greater than the happiness of buying the toy and taking it home?
Mr. McKibben went on to state that American happiness peaked in 1956 and has steadily declined since then. The host took him to task, stating that this may come from many other factors. Mr. McKibben countered him by stating that our consumption has gone up! This dialogue made me believe that Mr. McKibben’s logical skills may not be quite up to snuff. He seemed unwilling to break from his premise that more consumption was making us less happy, but similarly, seemed not to realize that this idea is nothing new.
To be fair to Mr. McKibben, his book does a lot of good in addressing ways to live while consuming less, societies where they seems to be working it without massive consumerism, and addresses both the economic and ecological impact of such living. But that doesn’t stop me from wanting to dig deeper into the information he presented.
Assuming my premise is correct (that people already know buying more stuff won’t truly make them happier, and that may be an incorrect assumption), we’ve got to think a little bit more about why American happiness has gone down. Presumably, it is because something else has risen or fallen along with the happiness. I would propose that, while happiness has fallen, consumption has risen. And while consumption has risen, the amount of things to consume has also risen. And while that rises, so does the amount of information we are bombarded with. Breaking it down, because consumerism is so high, Mr. McKibben’s book can be published. So too can shows like To The Best Of Our Knowledge exist. And thus, we are constantly reminded that our consumption is actually NOT making us happy, and that it in fact does affect the world in some very real, and very negative, ways.
So when I buy a new computer (as I did just a week ago), I got to see where it came from. Seeing it come from China got me thinking about the world economy. Thinking about that made me realize that buying a computer that came from China meant that, while I paid less, it was one less person in the US making a good wage and contributing to our economy. Suddenly, the happiness that comes from my new computer is partially lessened by the fact that I am, in a small part, contributing to globalization, a force that I consider to be, at least in part, bad.
The other thing that happens with this rise in information is that we start to understand the affect of US foreign policy on the rest of the world. Let’s think about post WWII America. We were the kings! We just took on a huge enemy and walked away the victors. The nation had pulled together and liberated the world from tyranny. Our boys were back and the economy was at a fevered pace. But then something happened – the Cold War. So even though we were so great and strong, there was another nation who could wipe us all out – a force that could destroy the entire planet. We had fallout shelters, bomb drills, and a real enemy staring us down the barrel of a huge nuclear gun. Suddenly, some of our arrogance as Americans didn’t seem so cool. And now, I see on the news everyday the price of our poor foreign policy. We’ve got wars going on in other countries, terrorists trying to kill civilians, and an idiot in the White House. I’m happy with my life, but I sure ain’t dancing in the streets.
So maybe Mr. McKibben does deal with all this information in his book. I would encourage you all to read it and let me know. But based on the interview I heard, I don’t think he’s offering any thing we haven’t heard before. And I don’t think that he’s really thinking too carefully about what all is going on in the heads of Americans. We may consume more than any other country on earth, but we sure aren’t blind about it.